Fudgy Buckeyes

November 16, 2016 By: Comments
Tagged: 4th of July 4th of July. Desserts Desserts. Vegetarian Vegetarian. Graduation Graduation. Labor Day Labor Day. Labor Day Labor Day. Game Day Game Day. Valentine's Day Valentine's Day. Kid Friendly Kid Friendly. Christmas Christmas. Candy Candy. Graduation Graduation. Christmas Christmas. Easter Easter. Snack Time Snack Time. Stovetop Stovetop. Desserts Desserts. Sugar Sugar. Comfort Foods Comfort Foods. Kid Friendly Kid Friendly. Hors d'Ouevres Hors d'Ouevres. Christmas Desserts Christmas Desserts. Chocolate Chocolate. Desserts Desserts. Valentine's Day Valentine's Day. 4th of July 4th of July. Comfort Foods Comfort Foods. Party Party. Gluten-Free Gluten-Free. Memorial Day Memorial Day. Butter Butter. Memorial Day Memorial Day. Game Day Game Day. Peanut Butter Peanut Butter. Chocolate Candy Chocolate Candy. Easter Easter. Birthdays Birthdays. Valentine's Day Desserts Valentine's Day Desserts. Christmas Christmas. Valentine's Day Valentine's Day.
45 minutes
1 minute
The only buckeyes I don't like are the ones that play against the Iowa Hawkeyes! But, when it's peanut butter dipped in chocolate to resemble the nut that grows on trees, I'm down! Buckeyes are a favorite in our family and I love to make mine with a fudgy peanut butter filling. I also love that there is no baking involved. These little dessert poppers are great for pretty much any party!


Select ingredients:


  1. Use an electric mixer to combine butter, marshmallow creme, vanilla, peanut butter, salt and honey.
  2. Make sure the filling is lump free.
  3. Slowly add in the powdered sugar on low speed.
  4. The fudgy filling should resemble cookie dough. If it's not thick enough, mix in more powdered sugar. Refrigerate filling for 30 minutes.
  5. Once the filling is chilled, roll into tablespoon sized balls. Add toothpicks and chill while the chocolate is melting.
  6. Warm up chocolate in a chocolate melter or over the stove. I used the Food Lion chocolate bark.
  7. Dip and swirl the buckeyes into the chocolate. Leave a little peekaboo hole at the top to make the dessert resemble a buckeye. *You could add team colored sprinkles on top when they are wet if you want to get fancy.
  8. Enjoy!